Consistency in drafting

Consistency.

Consistency matters a lot when drafting agreements.

I was half amused and half exasperated when I saw an amended draft shareholders’ agreement which stated that shareholders may exercise certain rights by giving notice to the other shareholders. The next clause stated that the shareholders shall give notice to the board who will then give notice to the other shareholders to exercise the rights.

Inconsistency usually arises when drafts are amended multiple times and the drafter does not realise the newly amended Clause 5 in the sixth draft is inconsistent with Clause 6 which has been there since the first draft.

#malaysiancorporatelawyer
#mergersandacquisitions
#shareholdersagreement

This post was first posted on Linkedin on 5 November 2022.

Linkedin Post
Partial Share Sales in Malaysia: What Sellers Need to Know About Guarantees

In partial disposals, it’s common for sellers and buyers to agree that any existing guarantees given by the sellers to secure banking facilities of the target companies will be adjusted to reflect the post-completion shareholding. For public listed companies (PLCs) in Malaysia, this can affect the deal timeline if not …

Linkedin Post
M&A Break Fees: Practical Constraints in Malaysia

In M&A transactions, break fees refer to a pre-agreed sum payable if a party withdraws from a proposed transaction without any breach by the counterparty. In principle, break fees are intended to deter frivolous exits and to compensate the other party for transaction-related costs, including due diligence and advisory expenses. …

Linkedin Post
M&A Disclosure Letter: DIY or Get a Lawyer?

In M&A transactions, a disclosure letter sets out the exceptions and qualifications to the representations and warranties (R&Ws) given by a seller in a share sale and purchase agreement (SPA). Getting it wrong can turn an unintentional misstatement into a breach of contract, with serious legal and financial consequences. Should …