Why You Need a Separate Subscription Agreement from a Shareholders’ Agreement?

Contracts

Should/ could a subscription agreement be combined with a shareholders’ agreement?

While it’s possible to combine the two agreements, I prefer to have a subscription agreement separate from a shareholders’ agreement for the following reasons:

  1. The parties to the agreements are different. The subscription agreement primarily involves the company which issues the shares. On the other hand, a shareholders’ agreement doesn’t necessarily require the company to be a party to the agreement unless the company has rights and obligations under the shareholders’ agreement.
  1. In a shareholders’ agreement, the shareholders may give representations and warranties to the other shareholders. However, in a subscription agreement, the company is the key party which gives representations and warranties to the subscriber although in certain cases, the founders/ other shareholders may also provide representations and warranties to the subscriber.
  1. A subscription agreement and a shareholders’ agreement serve different purposes. A subscription agreement is meant to be a one-off document that sets out the subscription terms which are typically not revisited after the subscription is completed. Conversely, the shareholders’ agreement governs the ongoing relationship between the shareholders and continue to bind the shareholders after the subscription.

Due to the distinctions between a subscription agreement and shareholders’ agreement as set out above, having two separate agreements provides better clarity.

It’s certainly not because lawyers want to charge more.

#malaysiancorporatelawyer

This post was posted on LinkedIn on 21 December 2023.

Due Diligence
Legal Due Diligence on Public Listed Companies in Malaysia

When conducting legal due diligence on public listed companies (PLCs) in Malaysia, the scope of due diligence is limited by the laws of insider trading. Insider trading occurs when someone uses confidential, non-public information about a company to make a profit or avoid a loss in the stock market. Therefore, …

Linkedin Post
Don’t Rush the Disclosure Letter in M&A Transactions

In M&A transactions, a disclosure letter sets out the exceptions to seller’s representations and warranties in a sale and purchase agreement for an M&A transaction (“SPA”). Instead of negotiating heavily on sellers’ representations and warranties in SPAs, it is common to provide in SPAs that sellers’ representations and warranties are …

Lawyering
Is Corporate Practice Less Stressful Than Litigation?

I was asked whether being in corporate practice is less stressful and less hectic than being in litigation practice. I think this kind of generalisation is not particularly helpful. Different law firms have different cultures and expectations of their lawyers. Clients’ demand would also determine whether a particular project or …