Beware of drafting error

Drafting

A simple error in drafting could create a problem in the future.

Consider the following scenario.

A shareholders’ agreement sets out board composition and right of shareholders to nominate directors.

A shareholder who holds majority of the shares in the company would usually have the right to nominate more directors than a shareholder who holds less shares.

Say there are two shareholders in the company.

The shareholders agree that the company should have five directors, with the shareholder who holds majority of the shares having the right to appoint three directors and the other shareholder who holds less shares having the right to appoint two directors.

When drafting, if you accidentally flip the number of directors such that the agreement states that the shareholder who holds majority of the shares may appoint two directors and the other shareholder may appoint three directors, this will create unintended consequences of allowing the minority shareholder to have board control.

To err is human.

Always check your work.

It is good practice to have at least two persons reviewing draft agreement.

#malaysiancorporatelawyer
#contractdrafting
#shareholdersagreement
#mergersacquisitions

This post was first posted on Linkedin on 22 June 2022.

Lawyering
The Kindness That Stays, 20 Years On

I last saw them in 2007. They are two kind souls who made my years studying in the UK such a beautiful chapter in my life. I have been thinking about them lately and finally reached out after all these years. Whenever I look back on my time in the …

Linkedin Post
Why M&A Deals Fail

As an M&A lawyer, most of my time goes into the legal documents – drafting and negotiating agreements, representations, warranties, conditions precedent, etc. However, the deals I have seen delayed or aborted were not because of legal documents. A deal was aborted when geopolitical tension escalated while parties were going …

Linkedin Post
When a Seller is Paid in Shares, Instead of Cash

In an M&A transaction, a buyer which is also a company may offer to pay by issuing its own shares to the seller, instead of paying in cash. How is this different compared to a cash deal? The seller is not just selling. The seller is also “buying” into the …